fbpx
  • Latest News
  • Trending News
  • All
  • Latest News
  • Featured
  • Industry News
  • Legal Governance
  • Constitutional Law
  • Op-Ed
  • News Archives
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Analysis
  • Bankruptcy Law
  • Consumer Protection Law
  • Cyber Security Law
  • Family Law
  • Disability Law
  • Employment Law
  • Environmental Law
  • Estate Law
  • Housing Law
  • Human Rights Code
  • Immigration Law
  • Insurance Law
  • Intellectual Property Law
  • Privacy Law
  • Tax Law
  • Workers Compensation Board
Deduction of CERB From Wrongful Dismissal Damages

Deduction of CERB From Wrongful Dismissal Damages

April 10, 2022
Personal information about more than 100 military sex misconduct claimants leaked

Personal information about more than 100 military sex misconduct claimants leaked

June 19, 2022
This law professor has become the 1st Canadian on UN’s disabilities rights committee

This law professor has become the 1st Canadian on UN’s disabilities rights committee

June 17, 2022
The Groundhog Day Privacy Bill The Government Waited Months to Bring Back Roughly the Same Privacy Plan!

The Groundhog Day Privacy Bill The Government Waited Months to Bring Back Roughly the Same Privacy Plan!

June 17, 2022
Women working with RCMP suffered ‘shocking’ levels of violence, sex assaults, says report

Women working with RCMP suffered ‘shocking’ levels of violence, sex assaults, says report

June 17, 2022
Retired priest, 92, charged with assault in Manitoba residential school case

Retired priest, 92, charged with assault in Manitoba residential school case

June 17, 2022
Security at the Supreme Court must be a priority

Security at the Supreme Court must be a priority

June 17, 2022
Taxpayer hit with a TFSA overcontribution penalty takes the CRA to court

Taxpayer hit with a TFSA overcontribution penalty takes the CRA to court

June 16, 2022
Ottawa poised to amend extreme intoxication law after Supreme Court ruling

Ottawa poised to amend extreme intoxication law after Supreme Court ruling

June 16, 2022
Trudeau Liberals to table privacy bill for personal data, new AI rules

Trudeau Liberals to table privacy bill for personal data, new AI rules

June 16, 2022
‘Breathe life into our own laws’: Visions for the future of Indigenous child welfare in B.C.

‘Breathe life into our own laws’: Visions for the future of Indigenous child welfare in B.C.

June 16, 2022
Privacy bill sets out rules on use of personal data, artificial intelligence

Privacy bill sets out rules on use of personal data, artificial intelligence

June 16, 2022
Backlogged justice system can’t return to pre-pandemic ways, chief justice warns

Backlogged justice system can’t return to pre-pandemic ways, chief justice warns

June 16, 2022
Court of Appeal upholds tribunal decision on pay equity for Ontario midwives

Court of Appeal upholds tribunal decision on pay equity for Ontario midwives

June 15, 2022
Canada’s military police charge retired lieutenant-general with sexual assault

Canada’s military police charge retired lieutenant-general with sexual assault

June 15, 2022
Money laundering public inquiry finds ‘no evidence’ of political corruption in B.C.

Money laundering public inquiry finds ‘no evidence’ of political corruption in B.C.

June 15, 2022
CRTC imposes $7.5 million in penalties on Bell Canada for violations of Canada’s Telecommunications Act

CRTC imposes $7.5 million in penalties on Bell Canada for violations of Canada’s Telecommunications Act

June 15, 2022
Prisons are failing to comply with solitary confinement reforms: senators

Prisons are failing to comply with solitary confinement reforms: senators

June 15, 2022
Government lifts vaccination policy for federal workers

Government lifts vaccination policy for federal workers

June 15, 2022
With more kids working and getting hurt on the job, Quebec to review labour laws

With more kids working and getting hurt on the job, Quebec to review labour laws

June 15, 2022
Toronto police statistics show disproportionate use of force on Black people

Toronto police statistics show disproportionate use of force on Black people

June 15, 2022
Police told Marco Mendicino Freedom Convoy was peaceful: memo

Police told Marco Mendicino Freedom Convoy was peaceful: memo

June 15, 2022

This Ontario restaurant chain owes over $35K in unpaid wages. Workers, vendors now ask: What can be done?

June 15, 2022
B.C. report on money laundering calls for sweeping change, including more rules from legal regulator

B.C. report on money laundering calls for sweeping change, including more rules from legal regulator

June 15, 2022
Ont. CA strikes wrongful dismissal ruling after judge weighed factors beyond termination clause

Ont. CA strikes wrongful dismissal ruling after judge weighed factors beyond termination clause

June 15, 2022

This fall the SCC will hear the case Canadian Council for Refugees v. Minister of Citizenship and Immigration

June 15, 2022
‘Elephant in the room’: Judge addresses impact of SCC ruling in van attack case

‘Elephant in the room’: Judge addresses impact of SCC ruling in van attack case

June 14, 2022
Common offenses that make people inadmissible to Canada

Common offenses that make people inadmissible to Canada

June 14, 2022
Failing to report cyberattacks could mean penalties for key enterprises under new law

Failing to report cyberattacks could mean penalties for key enterprises under new law

June 14, 2022
Toronto police chief expected to apologize to Black community over use of force: sources

Toronto police chief expected to apologize to Black community over use of force: sources

June 14, 2022
Pro Bono Ontario launches refugee legal relief initiative for Ukrainians seeking refuge in Canada

Pro Bono Ontario launches refugee legal relief initiative for Ukrainians seeking refuge in Canada

June 13, 2022
  • ABOUT LITN
  • SUPPORT LITN
  • LEGAL, PRIVACY & POLICY
  • PUBLIC EDUCATION & RESOURCE LINKS
Sunday, June 26, 2022
  • Login
  • Register for a FREE LITN account
⚖ Law in the News .com (LITN) Media 📃
  • Latest News
  • Industry News
  • Categories
    • A to C
      • Aboriginal Law
      • Access to Justice (A2J)
      • Administrative Law
      • Alternative Dispute Resolution
      • Analysis
      • Animal Law
      • Anti-Corruption Law
      • Antitrust Law
      • Arbitration Law
      • Banking and Securities Law
      • Bankruptcy Law
      • Cannibis Law
      • Civil Litigation
      • Class Action
      • Commercial Law
      • Constitutional Law
      • Construction Law
      • Consumer Protection Law
      • Contract Law
      • Criminal Law
      • Cyber Security Law
    • D to H
      • Disability Law
      • Editor’s Choice
      • Elder Law
      • Employment Law
      • Environmental Law
      • Entertainment Law
      • Estate Law
      • Family Law
      • Highway Traffic Law
      • Housing Law
      • Human Rights Code
    • I to L
      • Immigration Law
      • Industry News
      • Insurance Law
      • Intellectual Property Law
      • International Law
      • Labour Law
      • Latest News
      • Legal Governance
    • M to Z
      • Medical Law
      • Municipal Law
      • Op-Ed
      • Personal Injury Law
      • Privacy Law
      • Real Estate Law
      • Tax Law
      • Telecommunications Law
      • Transportation Law
      • Workers Compensation Board
  • Archives
    • 2022
      • May 2022
      • April 2022
      • March 2022
      • February 2022
      • January 2022
    • 2021
      • December 2021
      • November 2021
      • October 2021
      • September 2021
      • August 2021
  • About LITN
    • Who We Are
    • Contact LITN
    • Support LITN
      • Contribute to LITN Operations
      • Place YOUR Custom Ad on LITN
      • Engage with LITN Sponsored Ads
      • Create a FREE LITN Account
      • Subscribe to the LITN Newsletter
      • Connect, Follow, Like, Retweet and Repost LITN
    • Legal, Privacy and Policy
      • Cookie Policy (CA)
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
  • Public Education and Resource Links
No Result
View All Result
⚖ Law in the News .com (LITN) Media 📃
  • Latest News
  • Industry News
  • Categories
    • A to C
      • Aboriginal Law
      • Access to Justice (A2J)
      • Administrative Law
      • Alternative Dispute Resolution
      • Analysis
      • Animal Law
      • Anti-Corruption Law
      • Antitrust Law
      • Arbitration Law
      • Banking and Securities Law
      • Bankruptcy Law
      • Cannibis Law
      • Civil Litigation
      • Class Action
      • Commercial Law
      • Constitutional Law
      • Construction Law
      • Consumer Protection Law
      • Contract Law
      • Criminal Law
      • Cyber Security Law
    • D to H
      • Disability Law
      • Editor’s Choice
      • Elder Law
      • Employment Law
      • Environmental Law
      • Entertainment Law
      • Estate Law
      • Family Law
      • Highway Traffic Law
      • Housing Law
      • Human Rights Code
    • I to L
      • Immigration Law
      • Industry News
      • Insurance Law
      • Intellectual Property Law
      • International Law
      • Labour Law
      • Latest News
      • Legal Governance
    • M to Z
      • Medical Law
      • Municipal Law
      • Op-Ed
      • Personal Injury Law
      • Privacy Law
      • Real Estate Law
      • Tax Law
      • Telecommunications Law
      • Transportation Law
      • Workers Compensation Board
  • Archives
    • 2022
      • May 2022
      • April 2022
      • March 2022
      • February 2022
      • January 2022
    • 2021
      • December 2021
      • November 2021
      • October 2021
      • September 2021
      • August 2021
  • About LITN
    • Who We Are
    • Contact LITN
    • Support LITN
      • Contribute to LITN Operations
      • Place YOUR Custom Ad on LITN
      • Engage with LITN Sponsored Ads
      • Create a FREE LITN Account
      • Subscribe to the LITN Newsletter
      • Connect, Follow, Like, Retweet and Repost LITN
    • Legal, Privacy and Policy
      • Cookie Policy (CA)
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
  • Public Education and Resource Links
No Result
View All Result
⚖ Law in the News .com (LITN) Media 📃
No Result
View All Result
Home Employment Law

Deduction of CERB From Wrongful Dismissal Damages

The Ontario Superior Court of Justice noted that the CERB was an ad hoc program and it was not equitable to reduce the plaintiff’s entitlements accordingly.

April 10, 2022
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0
A A
0
Deduction of CERB From Wrongful Dismissal Damages
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare by Email
 
PHOTO: Stock
 
  • Omar Ha-Redeye ⁞ SLAW
  • April 10, 2022
 
 

During the pandemic, the federal government introduced several programs to provide financial assistance to those affected by economic lockdowns and business closures. The Canada Emergency Response Benefit program (CERB) provided $2,000 for an initial 4-week period, with an extension to 28-weeks for a maximum of $14,000.

Eligibility for CERB included:

  •  individuals residing in Canada;
  • who were at least 15 years old;
  • who had stopped working or had been working reduced hours due to COVID-19;
  • who did not expect to earn over $1,000 in employment or self-employment income for at least 14 days in a row during a four-week period;
  • who had employment or self-employment income of at least $5,000 in 2019 or in the 12 months prior to the date of their application; and
  • who had not quit their job voluntarily.

An analysis by Statistics Canada found that over a third of all Canadians who earned more than $5,000 in 2019 received CERB payments in 2020. As expected, industries worst affected by the pandemic such as accommodations and food services saw the greatest number of CERB payments, with women, low-wage, visible minority and Indigenous, and younger workers most likely to receive CERB.

For those workers laid off during the pandemic, the question has always remained whether CERB would be deducted from notice periods in wrongful dismissal claims. To date, no appellate court in Canada has resolved this issue, and decisions across jurisdictions provide different results.

In Iriotakis v. Peninsula Employment Services Limited, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice noted that the CERB was an ad hoc program that neither employer or employee paid into or earned over time, and it was not equitable to reduce the plaintiff’s entitlements accordingly.

In Hogan v 1187938 B.C. Ltd., the Supreme Court of British Columbia distinguished it from Iriotakis on the basis that the employment contract did not provide an entitlement to commission, and retaining the CERB payments would not have put the plaintiff in a better position. Applying the principles of contract law from IBM Canada Limited v. Waterman, the court found in this case it should be deducted.

The same court in Verigen v Ensemble Travel Ltd. distinguished Hogan because the plaintiff in that case signed a layoff notice, and there was a finding of constructive dismissal. Although the CERB payment was not deducted, it was because the payment was received during a 5 month layoff, which preceded the date that the court determined the termination occurred and was therefore not an issue that was addressed.

Conversely, the Provincial Court of Saskatchewan – Civil Division in Abdon v Brandt Industries Canada Ltd. chose to follow the holding in Hogan and not Iriotakis, deducting the CERB payment, but primarily because the latter decision was based in equitable considerations, and the provincial court did not have the same subject-matter jurisdiction as a court of inherent jurisdiction to apply the same principles.

The Supreme Court of Nova Scotia also found that CERB should not be deducted in Slater v. Halifax Herald Limited, based on an assumption that some people will have to pay back the CERB payment. The rationale used by the court was a comparison with Employment Insurance benefits, which are not typically deducted given an employee’s obligation to repay the federal government. The same basis was relied upon in the BC decision of Andrews v Allnorth Consultants Limited.

The BC court in Yates v Langley Motor Sport Centre Ltd. is the only one of these decisions that engaged directly with the statutory provisions, and concluded that CERB should be deducted based on a review of s. 6(1)(b) of the Canada Emergency Response Benefit Act. Based on the available evidence it did not appear that the CERB would need to be paid back.

Reotech Construction Ltd. v Snider came to yet another conclusion in BC, albeit in an appeal arising from small claims court. The decision not to deduct CERB was correct, but only because the trial judge did not have the benefit of Yates. The court concluded in the absence of any evidence that CERB would be repaid, it was an error in law or an error of mixed fact and law to deduct it.

The BC court’s most recent decision in Shalagin v Mercer Celgar Limited Partnership reviewed many of the forgoing cases, referenced judicial comity but also the lack of binding nature of these decisions, and deducted CERB on the basis of Hogan, Yates, and Abdon.

In Oostlander v Cervus Equipment Corporation, the Court of Queen’s Bench of Alberta, the court distinguished the case from Irotakis, Hogan and Snider, and deducted the CERB benefits from the plaintiff’s final damage award. The court refused to speculate whether CERB would have to be repaid. A failure to deduct CERB would result in double recovery. This decision was also notable given a 24 month notice period, given the extensive period of time they worked for the employer. 

This dizzying review of treatment of CERB could likely be attributed in large part to the uncertainties and confusion over the payment itself.

An estimated 1.7 million Canadians may need to pay CERB back to the government, though there will not be penalties or interest on overpayments. The reason how this occurred is explained by Erica Alini in The Globe,

The issue dates back to the early days of the CERB, when Ottawa distributed a $2,000 “advance” payment to many who applied for the benefit through Service Canada before June 14, 2020. The funds, which were in addition to the regular benefit of $500 a week, represented a four-week advance of future payments and were an effort to get money into people’s pockets as quickly as possible, the government said at the time.

Still others received payment when they may not have been eligible, or lost eligibility. The Government of Canada has a website that helps with determining whether CERB will need to be paid back to the CRA.

From a file management perspective, counsel should be making inquiry of their clients and the other side as to whether an overpayment letter has been received. They should also inquire whether the employee has logged in to their CRA account to check their CERB status.

Even then, it’s possible that a court will not base its decision on the need for repayment, and instead deduct CERB payments on the basis of avoiding any double recovery. Until there is an appellate decision on the subject it’s unlikely that there will be clarity on this point, and any settlement discussions navigating CERB payments will encounter challenges in identifying the appropriate legal principles at play.

 
 

 
GOOGLE ADVERTISEMENT

Want direct access to the latest LITN content?

Stay in the loop ➞ Subscribe to LITN instant notifications.
Receive the latest content delivered directly to your device.
Unsubscribe at anytime.

Unsubscribe from LITN instant notifications
Previous Post

(US) Accused shooter in Lady Gaga dog theft mistakenly freed

Next Post

(US) Google’s ‘privileged’ email labeling, said to prevent lawsuit disclosure, was ‘eyebrow raising,’ judge says

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to LITN's Terms & Conditions.

Latest News

Personal information about more than 100 military sex misconduct claimants leaked
Privacy Law

Personal information about more than 100 military sex misconduct claimants leaked

June 19, 2022
10
This law professor has become the 1st Canadian on UN’s disabilities rights committee
International Law

This law professor has become the 1st Canadian on UN’s disabilities rights committee

June 17, 2022
7
The Groundhog Day Privacy Bill The Government Waited Months to Bring Back Roughly the Same Privacy Plan!
Privacy Law

The Groundhog Day Privacy Bill The Government Waited Months to Bring Back Roughly the Same Privacy Plan!

June 17, 2022
3

Subscribe

Join the LITN Newsletter ➞ the latest news delivered to your inbox. Unsubscribe at any time.


GOOGLE ADVERTISEMENT

Instagram Feed

  • Personal Cognitive Bias example: Sampling Bias ...
Sampling bias is a kind of bias that allows us to come to faulty conclusions based on inaccurate sample groups or data. Generally, the cause of sample bias is in poor study design and data collection.  When polling individuals for survey questions, it is important to get a representative picture of an entire population. But this can prove surprisingly difficult when the people generating the study are also prone to human flaws, including cognitive biases.  To avoid sampling bias, it is important to randomize data collection to ensure responses are not skewed towards individuals with similar characteristics. #bias #personalbiases #cognitivebiases
  • Osgoode - 225th Anniversary 🎆🎉🎇
  • Osgoode - 225th Anniversary 🎆🎉🎇

Facebook Feed

Facebook Feed

Twitter Feed

Join the Conversation

Personal selections from a Canadian perspective. #Law in the #News #LITN @Law_In_The_News

News Categories

Latest Headlines

Personal information about more than 100 military sex misconduct claimants leaked

Personal information about more than 100 military sex misconduct claimants leaked

June 19, 2022
10
This law professor has become the 1st Canadian on UN’s disabilities rights committee

This law professor has become the 1st Canadian on UN’s disabilities rights committee

June 17, 2022
7
The Groundhog Day Privacy Bill The Government Waited Months to Bring Back Roughly the Same Privacy Plan!

The Groundhog Day Privacy Bill The Government Waited Months to Bring Back Roughly the Same Privacy Plan!

June 17, 2022
3

Subscribe to the LITN Newsletter

Join the LITN Newsletter ➞ the latest news delivered to your inbox. Unsubscribe at any time.

Website Powered By

DJT Design Studios logo

© 2022 Law in the News Media (LITN)

  • About LITN
  • Contact LITN
  • Support LITN
  • Legal, Privacy and Policy
  • Public Education & Resource Links
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Latest News
  • Industry News
  • Categories
    • A to C
      • Aboriginal Law
      • Access to Justice (A2J)
      • Administrative Law
      • Alternative Dispute Resolution
      • Analysis
      • Animal Law
      • Arbitration Law
      • Anti-Corruption Law
      • Antitrust Law
      • Banking and Securities Law
      • Bankruptcy Law
      • Cannibis Law
      • Criminal Law
      • Civil Litigation
      • Class Action
      • Commercial Law
      • Constitutional Law
      • Construction Law
      • Consumer Protection Law
      • Contract Law
      • Criminal Law
      • Cyber Security Law
    • D to H
      • Disability Law
      • Editor’s Choice
      • Elder Law
      • Employment Law
      • Environmental Law
      • Estate Law
      • Family Law
      • Highway Traffic Law
      • Housing Law
      • Human Rights Code
    • I to L
      • Immigration Law
      • Industry News
      • Insurance Law
      • Intellectual Property Law
      • International Law
      • Labour Law
      • Latest News
      • Legal Governance
    • M to Z
      • Medical Law
      • Municipal Law
      • Op-Ed
      • Personal Injury Law
      • Privacy Law
      • Real Estate Law
      • Tax Law
      • Telecommunications Law
      • Transportation Law
      • Workers Compensation Board
  • News Archives
    • 2022
      • May 2022
      • April 2022
      • March 2022
      • February 2022
      • January 2022
    • 2021
      • December 2021
      • November 2021
      • October 2021
      • September 2021
      • August 2021
  • Public Education & Resource Links
  • About LITN
    • Who We Are
    • Contact LITN
    • Support LITN
    • Legal, Privacy and Policy
      • Home
      • Cookie Policy
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use Policy

© 2022 Law in the News Media (LITN)

Welcome Back to LITN!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
Sign In with Linked In
OR

Login to your LITN account below.

Forgot your password? Sign Up

Create a FREE LITN Account!

Sign Up with Facebook
Sign Up with Google
Sign Up with Linked In
OR

Please complete your registration below.

*By registering into the website, you agree to LITN's Terms & Conditions.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
⚖ Law in the News .com (LITN) Media 📃
Manage Cookie Consent
LITN uses technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information to provide the best user experience. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}
Go to mobile version