More than 10,000 Canadians received a medically-assisted death in 2021: report
Quebec Superior Court suspends Bill 96โ€™s translation requirement until constitutionality determined
The Ontario government has given Maggie an ultimatum: the disabled teen can lose her funding or her independence
FBI took 11 sets of classified material from Trump’s Mar-a-Lago home while investigating possible Espionage Act violations (US)
Ontario class action settlement reclassifies volunteers as employees, setting new precedent
Availability of Judicial Review in SABS Disputes
Are masking policies still valid?
Justice Canada releases commission report on impact of lack of legal aid in family law disputes
Harmonized sales tax part of maximum amount of attendant care benefits owed by insurer: court
New rules coming next month to help Canadians with cancelled and delayed flights
Stephen King set to testify for govt in books merger trial (US)
New law program in Quebec to begin next fall, a first in 50 years
The Impact of the Lack of Legal Aid in Family Law Cases
SCC rules that when someone is required by their partner to wear a condom but do not, they could be guilty of sexual assault.
Big Plastic suing feds over single-use ban โ€” again
Tim Hortons offers coffee and doughnut as proposed settlement in class action lawsuit
The SCC has refused to hear the appeal to declare the renewal of the state of health emergency by the Quebec government invalid
Federal privacy commissioner investigating controversial ArriveCAN app
Kraken, a U.S. Crypto Exchange, Is Suspected of Violating Sanctions (US)
Ontario court certifies class action on former patients’ anxiety from notice of risk of infection
The stakes couldn’t be higher as Canada’s top court decides whether to hear climate class action lawsuit
Professor Barnali Choudhury selected by EU as trade and sustainable development expert
The Supreme Court decision on the โ€˜Ghomeshiโ€™ amendments will help sexual assault victims access justice
AFN Reaches $20 B Final Settlement Agreement to Compensate First Nations Children and Families

Nunavut Legal Aid to intervene at Supreme Court of Canada for first time

Nunavut Legal Aid is to have a say at the Supreme Court of Canada for the first time in a case that could affect the way Inuit are sentenced.


PHOTO: Madeleine Redfern, former mayor of Iqaluit, is pictured in Iqaluit on Dec. 10, 2014. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick


IQALUIT, NUNAVUT — Nunavut Legal Aid is to have a say at the Supreme Court of Canada for the first time in a case that could affect the way Inuit are sentenced.

About 40,000 people, mostly Inuit, live in the territory, which has the highest incarceration rate in the country.

Nunavut Legal Aid is to appear in Ottawa on Wednesday to intervene in R v. Sharma.

The case involves a young Indigenous woman named Cheyenne Sharma and the constitutionality of a law that barred a judge from allowing her to avoid jail by serving a conditional sentence.

Conditional sentences can be served in the community, typically in the form of house arrest.

Sharma pleaded guilty in 2016 to smuggling two kilograms of cocaine into Canada from South America. Evidence at trial showed Sharma was facing financial hardship and was going to be evicted from her home. She was sentenced to 17 months in custody.

In 2018, the Ontario Superior Court rejected Sharma’s application for a conditional sentence. The judge based the decision on a 2012 change to the federal Criminal Code that disallows community-based sentences for offences, like drug-trafficking, that carry maximum penalties.

An Ontario Court of Appeal justice, saying it was unconstitutional and that it discriminated against Indigenous offenders, rejected the law. The Crown then appealed to the Supreme Court.

Eva Tache-Green, a Nunavut Legal Aid lawyer leading the intervention, argues that limiting conditional sentences only hurts Inuit offenders across Nunavut.

In her submission to the Supreme Court, Tache-Green notes that Nunavut’s legal order is Inuit Qaujimajatuqangit, a social value system often interpreted as ‘what Inuit have always known to be true.'”

Tache-Green argues that restricting conditional sentences interferes with that approach, which focuses on rehabilitation instead of punishment, and takes more people out of their home communities.

“Elders consider modern imprisonment to be akin to banishment, which was among the harshest sanctions possible under Inuit law,” she wrote in a submission to the court.

Madeleine Redfern, chairwoman of Nunavut’s Legal Services Board, said it’s important that Indigenous peoples’ right to a conditional sentence be preserved.

“We’ve operated in that system for decades where conditional sentences were part of the option. That (federal) legislation simply took that option away,” she said.

Redfern said Nunavut, the youngest of Canada’s three territories, still has a chance to shape how justice is carried out.

“Nunavut and Inuit have still yet an opportunity to continue to shape how justice is done in our territory, which should include restorative justice.”

She conceded that not every offender should be given a conditional sentence, but suggested giving judges discretion will give Inuit a better chance of rehabilitation.

“These are real people. These are real lives. Often they are complicated and complex sets of circumstances that have led to an incident.”

Nunavut’s 25 communities are fly-in only, so Nunavummiut sentenced to custody are often taken hundreds, if not thousands, of kilometres from their homes.

โ€œSeparating Inuit offenders from their home communities weakens their prospects for rehabilitation,โ€ Tache-Green wrote in her submission.

She also argues the territoryโ€™s high prison rate shows how legislation that restricts conditional sentences can be harmful and has resulted in more Nunavummiut being sent to jail for longer periods of time.

โ€œLimits to the conditional sentence regime perpetuate the systemic disadvantages faced by Inuit offenders in Nunavut.”

Before the Criminal Code change, 357 Nunavummiut were sentenced to custody each year. That number has risen to 476 annually since then.

“Those numbers are only partly explained by population growth: Nunavutโ€™s population has grown by nearly 14 per cent since 2012, while the average number of custodial sentences has increased by 33 per cent,” Tache-Green wrote.

Other interveners in the case include the Ontario Native Women’s Association, the Elizabeth Fry Society and the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs.

This report by The Canadian Press was first published March 21, 2022.

This story was produced with the financial assistance of the Facebook and Canadian Press News Fellowship


Want direct access to the latest LITN content?

Stay in the loop โžž Subscribe to LITN instant notifications.
Receive the latest content delivered directly to your device.
Unsubscribe at anytime.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to LITN's Terms & Conditions.

Latest News


Join the LITN Newsletter โžž the latest news delivered to your inbox. Unsubscribe at any time.


Instagram Feed