More than 10,000 Canadians received a medically-assisted death in 2021: report
Quebec Superior Court suspends Bill 96’s translation requirement until constitutionality determined
The Ontario government has given Maggie an ultimatum: the disabled teen can lose her funding or her independence
FBI took 11 sets of classified material from Trump’s Mar-a-Lago home while investigating possible Espionage Act violations (US)
Ontario class action settlement reclassifies volunteers as employees, setting new precedent
Availability of Judicial Review in SABS Disputes
Are masking policies still valid?
Justice Canada releases commission report on impact of lack of legal aid in family law disputes
Harmonized sales tax part of maximum amount of attendant care benefits owed by insurer: court
New rules coming next month to help Canadians with cancelled and delayed flights
Stephen King set to testify for govt in books merger trial (US)
New law program in Quebec to begin next fall, a first in 50 years
The Impact of the Lack of Legal Aid in Family Law Cases
SCC rules that when someone is required by their partner to wear a condom but do not, they could be guilty of sexual assault.
Big Plastic suing feds over single-use ban — again
Tim Hortons offers coffee and doughnut as proposed settlement in class action lawsuit
The SCC has refused to hear the appeal to declare the renewal of the state of health emergency by the Quebec government invalid
Federal privacy commissioner investigating controversial ArriveCAN app
Kraken, a U.S. Crypto Exchange, Is Suspected of Violating Sanctions (US)
Ontario court certifies class action on former patients’ anxiety from notice of risk of infection
The stakes couldn’t be higher as Canada’s top court decides whether to hear climate class action lawsuit
Professor Barnali Choudhury selected by EU as trade and sustainable development expert
The Supreme Court decision on the ‘Ghomeshi’ amendments will help sexual assault victims access justice
AFN Reaches $20 B Final Settlement Agreement to Compensate First Nations Children and Families

Ontario auto claimants seek leave to appeal HST dispute to Supreme Court

A dispute over the handling of sales tax in Ontario auto accident benefits claims could reach the Supreme Court of Canada.

PHOTO: Stock photo

A dispute over the handling of sales tax in Ontario auto accident benefits claims could reach the Supreme Court of Canada.

In 2018, several auto clients filed lawsuits in Ontario against accident benefits insurers. Plaintiffs allege those carriers either included harmonized sales tax in the calculation of the claimants’ entitlements, or that the carriers paid only the cost of benefits without the sales tax that the clients had to pay.

Allegations against insurers, the province’s financial services regulator, and certain individuals have not been proven in court.

In 2020, a judge dismissed several proposed class actions against insurers. That ruling was upheld in Dorman v. Economical Mutual Insurance Company, released May 13, 2021 by the Court of Appeal for Ontario.

The Supreme Court of Canada announced Oct. 8 that Bradley Dorman is filing for leave to appeal. There are more than 30 parties listed on the Supreme Court of Canada docket.

When people buy goods and services in Ontario, they are often charged an additional 13% in harmonized sales tax. Some of that tax goes to the federal government while some goes to the provincial treasury.

An unproven allegation is that some insurers either included harmonized sales tax in the calculation of the benefit entitlements, or that they paid only the cost of benefits without the HST.

In 2020, Justice Edward Belobaba of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice ruled that it is the Licence Appeal Tribunal – not the Superior Court – that has exclusive jurisdiction over auto accident benefits dispute. For this reason, both Justice Belaboba – and three appeal court judges – agree that the class actions cannot proceed. In 2016, the LAT took over responsibility for auto accident benefits disputes from the Financial Services Commission of Ontario.

Now that plaintiffs are applying for leave to appeal the Dorman ruling, it is up to the Supreme Court of Canada to decide whether or not it will hear an appeal. Often the top court dismisses leave applications without giving reasons.

In addition to Economical, the other insurers listed as parties are Allstate Insurance Company of Canada, Belair Direct, Intact Insurance, Aviva Insurance Company of Canada, Unifund Assurance Company, Certas Home and Automobile Insurance Company, Commonwealth Mutual Insurance Group, Co-operators General Insurance Company, Echelon General Insurance Company, Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Company, St. Paul Fire and Marine Insurance Company, Travelers Insurance Company of Canada, TD Insurance, Gore Mutual Insurance Company and CUMIS General Insurance Company.

In Ontario auto, the HST issue is mainly affecting claimants whose injuries fall under the minor injury guideline, said Paul Harte, a lawyer representing one of the claimants, in a 2018 interview. The MIG has a ceiling of $3,500 for treatment for soft-tissue injuries such as whiplash.

Some treatments for auto accident injuries – such chiropractic treatment or physiotherapy – are not taxed, Harte told Canadian Underwriter earlier. On the other hand, massage therapy is subject to HST, as is home care if the service is not supplied by the government or by an organization administering home care on the government’s behalf.

GOOGLE ADVERTISEMENT

Want direct access to the latest LITN content?

Stay in the loop ➞ Subscribe to LITN instant notifications.
Receive the latest content delivered directly to your device.
Unsubscribe at anytime.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to LITN's Terms & Conditions.

Latest News

Subscribe

Join the LITN Newsletter ➞ the latest news delivered to your inbox. Unsubscribe at any time.


GOOGLE ADVERTISEMENT

Instagram Feed